"A New York Treasure" --Village Voice

Observations From Cooperstown: Nicknames, No. 2, and Marcus Thames

Over at The Hardball Times, I feature a regular column detailing the history and origins of baseball nicknames. Since the Yankees have had their share of nicknames over their long history, it seems appropriate to highlight a few of the more memorable monikers in this space. So to start things off, and with apologies to the “Iron Horse,” the “Commerce Comet,” and “Mr. October,” here are five of my most favorite Yankee nicknames:

Phil Rizzuto: Whether it was as a ballplayer or as a broadcaster, who could not love a nickname like “The Scooter?” Rizzuto’s small physical stature, particularly his short legs, contributed to this label. While still in the minor leagues, veteran infielder Billy Hitchcock took note of Rizzuto’s fielding and running style and said to him, “Man, you’re not running, you’re scooting.” Hitchcock’s characterization caught on almost immediately, with teammates happily calling Rizzuto “Scooter.” For his part, Rizzuto loved the nickname. “It’s the best thing that ever happened to me,” Rizzuto once told Stephen Borelli of USA Today. “It could have been some other name they could have called me.” “Scooting” seemed to work for Rizzuto. He became one of the game’s best fielding shortstops of the 1940s and early fifties, eventually earning election to the Hall of Fame in 1994.

George Selkirk: The outfielder who had the misfortune of succeeding Babe Ruth in right field, Selkirk also had a distinctive way of running with his weight pressed onto the balls of his feet. Some of his teammates with the minor league Newark Bears of the International League noticed this tendency and dubbed him “Twinkletoes.” (And once you’ve got a nickname like that, you’re never getting rid of it.) The nickname followed him to the major leagues, where Selkirk established himself as a solid hitter for average who also drew plenty of walks. From 1936 to 1942, Twinkletoes played for six American League pennant winners and five world championship teams.

Walt Williams: Williams’ two Yankee seasons of 1974 and ‘75 coincided with the lost years at Shea Stadium, but “No Neck” made a stirring impression on those who followed the team during the lean years. The nickname perfectly described the head-and-shoulders region of Williams, a fireplug of an outfielder who also played for the White Sox and Indians. From a distance, Williams appeared to have no neck, his head seemingly sitting on his collarbone. The descriptive name was the brainchild of journeyman catcher John Bateman, one of Williams’ teammates during his first major league stop with the Houston Colt .45s. Along with a fitting nickname, No Neck Williams brought some color to his various major league stops He ate hamburgers voraciously, ala “Wimpy” in the old “Popeye” cartoons, and liked to cover his body in Vaseline both before and after games. Williams felt that it would be good for his skin, even if it did nothing to elongate his neck.

Jimmy Wynn: This underrated outfielder spent only part of one season in the Bronx, but his nickname, “The Toy Cannon,” is too good to pass up. At five feet, nine inches tall and 170 pounds, Wynn hardly struck the pose of a prototypical power hitter. Originally a prospect with the Astros, Wynn soon proved that appearances can be deceiving. Wynn hit with such remarkable power, even in a hitter’s bone yard like the old Astrodome, that a contingent of Astros fans began referring to him as “The Toy Cannon.” Whenever I hear the nickname, an image comes to mind of Wynn pulling a toy cannon by a string, as he slowly walks from the on-deck circle to the batter’s box. It’s a strange image to say the least, but it says something about the powerful connotations that come with such a visual nickname. The nickname was fully in place by the time that the Yankees signed the aging Wynn as a free agent in 1977. It’s just too bad that the Yankees hadn’t brought him to town sooner, when he was putting up big numbers and playing terrific defense for the Astros and the Dodgers.

Sal Maglie: Like Wynn, Maglie spent a short time in pinstripes, but his nickname has always stuck with me. As an aggressive right-hander who developed a reputation for throwing up and in against opposing hitters, it was only natural that he would be called “The Barber.” Never hesitant to provide hitters with baseball’s version of a “close shave,” Maglie owned special pride in pitching inside. “When I’m pitching, I own the plate,” Maglie explained to a reporter. Maglie also enhanced the nickname with his appearance. Given his perpetual five o’clock shadow, Maglie not only appeared more intimidating, but looked like he needed a shave himself. On both counts, The Barber became an appropriate label for the onetime Yankee who also spent time with the Dodgers and Giants…

***

The Yankees face very few positional battles as they approach the start of spring training, but the construction of the lineup does bring up the inevitable question: who will bat second behind Derek Jeter? New York Post columnist Joel Sherman, one of the sharpest baseball minds on the Big Apple beat, has come up with a very reasonable compromise. In his Thursday column, Sherman advocated using Curtis Granderson in the two-hole against righties, with Johnson taking up the spot against left-handers. Granderson has a career on-base percentage of .367 against righties and the kind of game-breaking speed that makes him a good candidate to bat between Jeter and Mark Teixeira. Sherman thinks teams will be more reluctant to bring in lefty specialists to face Granderson, knowing that Teixeira hits left-handers better than righties. And even if teams do bring in a left-hander just for Granderson, they’ll have to burn an additional reliever to face Tex and Alex Rodriguez. All in all, the Sherman plan makes sense to me…

***

As much as I frowned upon the recent signing of Randy Winn, I favor the import of once-and-future Yankee Marcus Thames to the same degree. Good-field, no-hit outfielders like Winn are a dime a dozen; his two home runs in 2009 (and that .353 slugging percentage) stand out like a pair of sore thumbs, no matter what the playing conditions of AT&T Field are like. But Thames brings to the Yankees a legitimate skill: the ability to hit left-handed pitching with prejudice. For a team that leans toward the left, Thames is a good, solid fit. He has a career slugging percentage of .516 against left-handers, which should make him very useful as a platoon partner for Brett “The Jet” Gardner in left field and as a backup to the oft-injured Nick Johnson at DH. This, of course, assumes that Thames makes the Opening Day roster. In order to clear space for Thames on the 40-man ledger, the Yankees will eventually have to clear a roster spot. That shouldn’t be too much of a problem; the Yankees can always offer Rule Five draftee Jamie Hoffmann back to the Dodgers, cut loose one of their extraneous pitching prospects, or simply place one of their injured players on the 60-day disabled list. Bottom line, I’ll be shocked if Thames does not come north for the Opening Day matchup with the Red Sox.

About a month ago, I decried the Yankees’ lack of depth in the outfield, but Brian Cashman has taken care of the problem with the signings of Thames and Winn, along with the acquisition of minor league speedster Greg Golson. One footnote on Winn: Since Jimmy Wynn was known as “The Toy Cannon,” can we now refer to Randy Winn as the “Popgun Pistol?”

Bruce Markusen writes “Cooperstown Confidential” for The Hardball Times.

Categories:  Bronx Banter  Bruce Markusen

Share: Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email %PRINT_TEXT

2 comments

1 williamnyy23   ~  Feb 12, 2010 1:48 pm

It's very unfair to lable Randy Winn has good field, not hit. In reality, he is a good field, average hit (career OPS+ of 99) outfielder. That combination is far from a dime a dozen.

2 Bruce Markusen   ~  Feb 13, 2010 11:21 am

William, I'd agree with you pre-2009, but he was awful this past season, both in terms of slugging and on-base percentage. Now in his mid-thirties, I think he's done as a hitter. I'd love to be wrong, but the combination of age and a bad season doesn't add up favorably.

feed Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email
"This ain't football. We do this every day."
--Earl Weaver